Recipe: Shepherd’s Pie Recipe
Due to popular demand (or the one comment I got about it!), here is the basic recipe I used to make the Shepherd’s Pie the other night. I used this recipe on Epicurious as my base.
Ingredients:
- left over leg of lamb cut into pieces (you could use meat cooked for the dish or leftovers – very versatile!)
- 3 russet potatoes
- fresh herbs (rosemary)
- 4-5 carrots
- 1/2c. peas
- 1.5 lbs spinach, kale, etc.
- 1/2 onion, finely chopped
- 1-2T butter
- 2T flour
- 1c + 2T milk (+extra for potatoes) – warmed
- 2T parmesan cheese
- pinch nutmeg
Prepare Potatoes & boil carrots:
- pierce potatoes and bake in lower third of oven for 45-50 minutes @ 450 degrees. (Bake the potatoes so they will be stiffer than steamed/boiled) Cool 10 minutes then scoop out flesh and put thru a ricer. Stir in milk, salt, pepper, etc. to taste.
- Cook carrots in boiling water ~ 10 minutes. Add peas for last 2-3 minutes. Rinse with cold water to stop cooking.
Make Creamed Kale (or spinach, etc.):
- Cook greens in 1″ boiling salted water until wilted, 1-2 minutes. Drain and rinse with cold water. Squeeze to remove water then coarsely chop.
- Cook onion in butter over medium heat stirring until softened, ~4 min. Whisk in flour and cook, stirring, ~ 2 min. Add warm milk and simmer, whisking, 3-4min. Whisk in parmesan, salt, pepper, & nutmeg to taste. Add spinach and cook until heated thru.
Put pie together & bake:
- In a deep pie dish spread meat on bottom evenly.
- Sprinkle carrots and peas over meat.
- Cover with creamed greens.
- Top with potatoes and smooth top with spoon. Brush/drizzle with butter if desired.
Bake ~1 hour @ 350 degress.
Note: I added the juices that were saved with the leftover lamb. Other than that I only used the creamed kale for liquid. This was enough and the taste was great.


